Raiders of the Lost Ark: Not-so-"Special" Edition

You knew it was inevitable. Paramount has a storied history of milking its franchises for multiple dips on every conceivable home video format known to man whenever something really big happens. They're especially bad when it comes to the "Star Trek" franchise - I can't tell you how many times it seemed inevitable to upgrade from VHS to laserdisc to DVD over the years. (BTW, I happened to find used copies of the Original Series' third season and Deep Space Nine's fifth and seventh seasons over at a local GameStop, along with an affordable used copy of Battlestar Galactica Season 2.0, so all that awaits me is scraping up enough money to get those DVD sets and begin rebuilding my DVD collections!) I remember shelling out $200 back in 1993 just to double-dip on getting the first six "Star Trek" films in a limited edition box set just to get a six-pack of trading cards and a watch - big whoop! And of course, I'm equally guilty of multi-dipping for the films and series on DVD.

So it should come as no surprise that Paramount is going the double-dip DVD route with the "Indiana Jones" trilogy, given its recent three-volume release of the "Young Indiana Jones" series and the upcoming theatrical release of "Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull" (man, is that film gonna rock or what!). Each of the first three Indy films have been released in newly-packaged and relabeled "special" editions, as well as a three-disc Adventure Collection.

The problem I have is that Paramount, as well as Wal-Mart and who knows how many other retail outlets, have publicly promoted that this is the "first" time that the "Indiana Jones" films have been released on DVD in a special edition. Let me see a show of hands out there... how many of you recall, say, about five years ago when the Indy trilogy was first released on DVD in a four-disc (or five-disc, if you got it at Best Buy) boxed set edition? How many of you went ape nuts over that DVD set? Count me among them - if my dad were still alive, he'd have loved that set (and the "Young Indy" volumes) as well. So why should Paramount publicly say that this is the "first" time these films are coming onto DVD? Makes no sense. I'll bet you that you could go into almost any video store and still find that four-disc box set on sale. Publicly promoting this trilogy as coming out "for the first time" is a major misnomer, and their PR department should know better than that.

As for the films themselves, each film's transfer is identical to the previous DVD set, in full anamorphic widescreen format, Dolby Digital 5.1 sound, and optional subtitles in English, Spanish, or French. So visually and sonically you're getting the same transfer that was afforded the films back in 2003.

What's new is the collection of extras included with each disc. Since I just picked up the "Raiders" disc, I'll go with the bonus content on this one (the "Temple of Doom" and "Last Crusade" DVDs were not available for review at this time). Starting off the disc is a preview trailer for the upcoming "Kingdom of the Crystal Skull" at the head of the disc. Remember how I griped about there being a lack of a trailer for the new film on the "Young Indy" sets? Well, this definitely satisfies my taste (along with the different TV spots I've been picking up along the way on USA, Sci-Fi, Spike, and other channels). Also included on this set is a new introduction to the film with series creators Steven Spielberg and George Lucas, which runs approximately 5-10 minutes. (Remember how, the last time that the trilogy was issued on DVD, it contained "new" interview segments with Spielberg, Lucas, and Harrison Ford? Here we go again...)

The remainder of the discs' supplements include a 12-minute feature called "The Indy Trilogy: A Crystal Clear Appreciation", which looks back at the first three films while offering some new interviews on the set of "Kingdom of the Crystal Skull". Another feature is "Snakes Alive!" (10 minutes), which looks at the Well of Souls sequence, while "The Melting Face" (4 minutes) shows how actor Ronald Lacey's face was modeled to melt in the final film. Storyboards galore accompany this disc - for "Raiders" there's some 400 storyboards alone! Finally, we have a preview trailer for Lego's upcoming "Indiana Jones" game for Playstation 3 and XBox 360, along with a playable PC demo. (Just the thought of a Lego Indiana Jones game makes me want to shell out $400 to buy a system!)

Still missing in action from this DVD release are a pair of vintage documentaries from 1981 - "Great Movie Stunts" (narrated by Harrison Ford) and "The Making of Raiders of the Lost Ark", both of which were issued on VHS from Paramount in the 1980's. For "Temple of Doom", there are two documentaries from 1984 - "Heroes and Sidekicks" (narrated by William Shatner) and "The Making of Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom" and a 60-second teaser trailer for "Temple of Doom" (first included on the very first VHS release of "Raiders") - that have never been released on VHS or DVD at all! Finally we have a 45-minute documentary, "Great Adventurers and their Quests" (narrated by Dennis Weaver), from 1989 that looks at the making of "The Last Crusade" and profiles some real-life Indys and their adventures. Where are all of these documentaries when the DVDs first came out? Where are they now? Still MIA, I'm afraid. (Thank goodness I recorded these onto DVD+R discs, turning my five-disc collection into an eight-disc box set blowout!)

So the bottom line is this: Is it worth shelling out the extra bucks to double-dip for around 30 minutes of extras on each disc? Well, if you got the set last time, then you could replace the film-only discs with these new releases. The main casualty from the original set is the bonus fourth disc of documentaries and featurettes on the making of the original trilogy. If you didn't get the set last time, it's worth getting the discs. It's really hard justifying the need to double-dip just to put a few extra bucks into Luca$'s cash-cow pockets to get a few new bonuses this time around. What would have made these new releases really worth it would have been to include feature-length running audio commentaries with Lucas and Ford (since Spielberg doesn't like audio commentaries) and much-ballyhooed deleted scenes (which we got hints at in the BTS footage on the first DVD set but still not represented at all, along with the remaining deleted footage from the original "Star Wars" trilogy), along with something extremely more substantial than what we get here in these new single-disc releases. Or maybe I should just hardwire my DVD player up to a computer and do my own podcast commentary on this film.

Indy may say, "It's not the years, it's the mileage," but in this case your mileage definitely varies.