Okay, I know that this was to have been the second part of my continuing series of analyses on the first volume of "The Adventures of Young Indiana Jones". But when this baby arrived on my doorstep, it was too good of an opportunity to pass up. So away we go!
In 2006 it seemed that the "Star Trek" franchise was, for all intents and purposes, dead. The fifth series "Enterprise" died in the ratings at the end of its fourth season. All of the series (including the animated incarnation from the 1970's) had been released on DVD, and Paramount was attempting something new with the first of five different Fan Collectives, which were nothing more than selected repackagings of episodes from the different series in cost-friendly sets. The only way to get new adventures was to either pick up the latest Pocket Books novels or surf the Internet for different fan-based productions. Even then, rumblings were abound of yet another feature film project. It looked like the franchise would go quietly into its 40th anniversary with nothing significant.
But someone asked the question, "What if we brought the Original Series back to television but with updated visual effects?" Several years before, fans had done a series of video tests with the second season episode "The Doomsday Machine", giving the special effects a much-needed makeover to compete with all of the current crops of television series and movies that were laden with spectacular visuals. In 2001, Paramount Home Video released the acclaimed Director's Edition of "Star Trek: The Motion Picture" with many completed visual effects. In addition, the then-recent slate of "Star Trek" series and movies, most notably "Deep Space Nine", "Voyager", "Enterprise", and the four "Next Generation" spinoff films, utilized state-of-the-art CGI effects to the max. One of the most celebrated DS9 episodes, "Trials and Tribble-ations", revisited the Original Series' "The Trouble with Tribbles", complete with many fresh visual effects and an equal number of subtle trickeries a la "Forrest Gump" that caught many fans off guard. The two series that needed the heaviest visual effects makeovers were the Original Series and TNG. Could such an attempt be accomplished? Could the original "Trek" return but with a fresh facelift?
This immediately sent shockwaves throughout Trekdom. To some it seemed like the perfect way to celebrate the Original Series' 40th anniversary. To others it seemed sacrilege. How dare they screw up the original 79 episodes we all grew up with and know so well? What would happen to the original masters of the episodes? Would they go by the wayside a la the original theatrical versions of the first three "Star Wars" films, long forgotten by the creators and discarded like yesterday's trash?
When the first remastered episodes came out in the fall of 2006, fans immediately sought out the major and minor makeovers to the classic Treks they knew by heart. Many of the effects were done as outright replacements to the original effects created in the 1960's, which were at the time state-of-the-art. Some of the effects were quite subtle, in the same way that some of the subtle makeovers in the Director's Edition of TMP were accomplished. Even the original Alexander Courage theme was given a new makeover, complete with a new orchestral adaptation and a digitized version of William Shatner's classic opening monologue. It was akin to putting a fresh coat of paint and a new engine into a '57 Chevy. But could this 2006 version of the Original Series ever replace the original episodes in fans' hearts? The debate continues to this day.
Now comes the first season of "Star Trek: The Original Series" from CBS Video in a new 10-disc combination standard DVD and HD-DVD set. I won't go back and comment on the episodes themselves, having already reviewed the first season in the complete season set back in 2004. Click here to read my original review on TrekWeb for a detailed look at the episodes and its content. While I'm not able to discuss or extol the HD-DVD features, my review is limited to the standard DVD presentation, though I will reference the HD-DVD information for completion's sake.
As with the previous 2004 DVD release, all 29 episodes of the first season of "Star Trek" are presented in their original 1966 airdates, in 1.33:1 full screen format. Sonically, this fresh update is a treat, with the standard DVD sound in English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround, LAS Mono (whatever that means), and French mono, with optional English, LAS, and French subtitles. The HD-DVD presentation features English Dolby True HD and LAS mono sound, with optional English and LAS subtitles.
The picture format is just absolutely stunning and breathtaking! It was like looking at the last couple of seasons of "Enterprise", particularly with all of the new digital effects in place. The picture is that crisp and clear - imagine what it looks like in HD-DVD format! Having grown up with the original 79 episodes over the years, seeing the newly minted visual effects seemed jarring at first. Still, this is the original "Star Trek" we're talking here, and with the advancements in DVD and HD-DVD technology, the only way it can look is better than ever.
The DVD packaging is reminiscent of the four "Enterprise" sets, with the set packaged in a clear plastic case that is smaller than the other series' packages, which means it'll take up less space on your DVD shelves. Housed inside the clear plastic case is the DVD package itself, with the discs in a clear plastic bookcase tray and banded with a yellow sleeve a la the 2004 DVD set. Inside is an insert for the other "Star Trek" DVD releases currently available, as well as an offer for a "Star Trek" phaser remote control.
The majority of the extras on this DVD set have been ported over from the previous 2004 set. This includes "The Birth of a Timeless Legacy", which discussed the series' origins; "Reflections on Spock", a new interview with Leonard Nimoy; "Life Beyond Trek: William Shatner", which profiled the actor's writings and involvement with horses; "To Boldly Go: Season One", a look at the first season's most memorable moments; "Sci-Fi Visionaries", which looked at the many noted science fiction writers who contributed to the series; and the series' episode preview trailers. In addition, the two bonus features that were included in the Best Buy bonus disc - "Kiss and Tell: Romance in the 24th Century" and "Trek Connections" - have also been brought over to this new DVD/HD-DVD combo set. There's no need for me to rehash my thoughts on these additional features, so all I'll say is go back and read my original review.
What is new does have interest to both long-time "Trek" fans and newcomers to the series. First off is "Spacelift: Transporting Trek into the 21st Century". This interesting feature explores the debated and controversial aspects of returning the series to television and updating all of the visual effects and sound to 2006 standards. You get to see rough animatics of the new visual effects, as well as comparisons between the original 1966-67 visual effects and their modern-day counterparts. It's definitely jarring, to say the least, but I will give credit to the CGI artists who made these effects both major and subtle happen.
We also have something that is quite unique when it comes to "Star Trek": outtakes and home movies! In "Billy Blackburn's Treasure Chest: Rare Home Movies and Special Memories", this program spotlights actor Billy Blackburn, who was featured as a background extra in many episodes of the series. During the series' production, Blackburn shot a number of eight-millimeter home movies on the "Star Trek" sets, showing the stars in more relaxed moments and preparing to shoot scenes from different episodes. Now this is a treat! Fans have long clamored for any vintage outtakes and behind-the-scenes films to be included on DVD, and seeing these home movies makes it all the more interesting yet poignant, considering that DeForest Kelley and James Doohan are no longer with us. Kudos to Mr. Blackburn for bringing these vintage films to DVD!
In addition, Perpetual Entertainment has a preview of its upcoming "Star Trek Online" MMO game, which takes the saga into the 25th century. There is also a new feature entitled "Star Trek: Beyond the Final Frontier" - whatever that means. All of these above features can be found on both the standard DVD and HD-DVD sides of the discs.
As if that weren't enough, HD-DVD owners will be in for even more treats. First of all, there is a new on-screen graphic interface program entitled "Starflet Access" on seven episodes - "Where No Man Has Gone Before", "The Menagerie, Parts 1 and 2", "Balance of Terror", "The Galileo Seven", "Space Seed", and "Errand of Mercy". In this interactive feature, viewers can access Picture-in-Picture video commentaries with surviving cast members and writers, comparisons of the remastered episodes with their original visual effects, episode trivia, and encyclopedic information used in the series. This is definitely a step or seven up from the text commentaries from Michael and Denise Okuda!
From there we have the "Interactive Enterprise Tour", in which viewers can explore the interior and exterior of the U.S.S. Enterprise in detail as they pilot their own shuttlecraft in this spectacular 3-D feature.
Obviously, as I said earlier, the majority of the bonus features from the 2004 DVD set were ported over to this new combo set. That means the Okuda text commentaries are the only significant extras that were left off this new set. For that matter, the previous set had a series of "Red Shirt Logs", a series of bonus hidden Easter eggs that contained additional interview segments - I don't know if these have also been ported over from the previous 2004 set.
As with the previous sets, missing in action are a wealth of additional extras that could have greatly enhanced the overall completeness of "Star Trek" on DVD. Of course, I'm talking about the two direct-to-VHS documentaries, "William Shatner's Star Trek Memories" and "Inside Star Trek: The Real Story", both of which feature interviews with cast and production members no longer with us (among them De Kelley, Jimmy Doohan, director James Goldstone, and makeup artist Wah Chang). Furthermore, vintage TV spots promoting the series during its premiere and first two seasons are missing, as well as the infamous blooper reels, production outtakes (can we say Jeffrey Hunter outtakes from "The Cage"?), and deleted scenes that we know exist and have been well documented all across the Internet.
Most conspicuously, the original versions of the first season episodes have been left off. This means forcing the consumer to double-dip to get not only this newly enhanced "Trek" but also the additional bonus features. Not many people are going to enjoy the fact that the original episodes we all grew up with and know so well have been omitted from this DVD/HD combo set. Remember Fox's "Star Wars Trilogy" debacle from 2004, leaving off the original versions of the trilogy? (Of course, it would take another couple of years before getting the originals onto DVD, but in really crappy form, but that's another argument for another place and time.)
Finally, who in their right or left mind is going to spend $217 to get this 10-disc set? When the price tag for this set was announced at this past summer's Comic-Con, how many people didn't mind wanting to pay the high price tag for this set? A grand total of three people. The rest of the hundreds and thousands in attendance gave it a good ol' Stone Cold "Hell, no!" Why didn't CBS and Paramount listen to the fans for once? It's a no-brainer that you'll find this set for probably $150 in stores. For that matter, you can go to your local Wal-Mart and pick up all three seasons of the original "Trek" (in their original forms!) for about the same price as you would spend for this remastered version. Which sounds like the better deal? You do the math.
Yes, "Star Trek" is back and in remastered form, with newly improved picture and sound. So why am I giving it only three stars out of five? It's hard for me to give this set a firmly satisfied recommendation, given all that was left off the new release. But since this is like buying a vintage car with a fresh paint job and high-tech engine, it does merit a decent recommendation. Of course, long-time fans will bemoan the loss of the original versions of their beloved episodes in this new set. As with everything, your mileage may vary.
Okay, next time, I promise, will be my second part of the "Young Indy" review. See you then!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment